Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sairam Sundaresan's avatar

This was poignant, beautiful and the best thing I've read all day!

Expand full comment
Malavika Mudit's avatar

What a fantastic essay, Michelle. I love your voice - I can actually kind of hear you reading it in my head because I'm quite the voice in my head reader - and I admire the way you set up, explain and then gently but sharply take apart "manufactured reciprocity."

I echo your sense that WOP challenges theories of reciprocity, and I was happily testing out the theory (in my head) that people don't always function on reciprocity - as some cooperation theorists seem to argue.

But I'd never thought it about it in this way - that sometimes we imagine that reciprocity is possible in situations where it isn't, cannot or shouldn't be a factor. Worse still, we then see everything through the lens of reciprocity in those imagined situations. Giving without expectation can fuel more of that kind of giving without expectation - which is an organic and elevated reciprocity itself.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts